共计 34536 个字符，预计需要花费 87 分钟才能阅读完成。
简介
从源码层面具体解说了 qiankun 框架中的 JS 沙箱 和 款式沙箱的实现原理。
序言
沙箱 这个词想必大家应该不生疏，即便生疏，读完这篇文章也就不那么生疏了
沙箱 (Sandboxie)，又叫沙盘，即是一个虚构零碎程序，容许你在沙盘环境中运行浏览器或其余程序，因而运行所产生的变动能够随后删除。它发明了一个相似沙盒的独立作业环境，在其外部运行的程序并不能对硬盘产生永久性的影响。在网络安全中，沙箱指在隔离环境中，用以测试不受信赖的文件或应用程序等行为的工具
而明天要说的沙箱来自 qiankun 的实现，是为了解决微前端计划中的隔离问题，qiankun 目前能够说的最好的 微前端 实现计划吧，它基于 single-spa 做了二次封装，解决了 single-spa 遗留的泛滥问题， 运行时沙箱 就是其中之一
为什么须要它
single-spa 虽好，但却存在一些须要在框架层面解决但却没有解决的问题，比方为每个微利用提供一个洁净、独立的运行环境
JS 全局对象净化是一个很常见的景象，比方：微利用 A 在全局对象上增加了一个本人特有的属性 window.A，这时候切换到微利用 B，这时候如何保障 window对象是洁净的呢？答案就是 qiankun 实现的 运行时沙箱
总结
先上总结，运行时沙箱分为 JS 沙箱 和 款式沙箱
JS 沙箱
JS 沙箱，通过 proxy 代理 window 对象，记录 window 对象上属性的增删改查
-
单例模式
间接代理了原生 window 对象，记录原生 window 对象的增删改查，当 window 对象激活时复原 window 对象到上次行将失活时的状态，失活时复原 window 对象到初始初始状态
-
多例模式
代理了一个全新的对象，这个对象是复制的 window 对象的一部分不可配置属性，所有的更改都是基于这个 fakeWindow 对象，从而保障多个实例之间属性互不影响
将这个 proxy 作为微利用的全局对象，所有的操作都在这个 proxy 对象上，这就是 JS 沙箱的原理
款式沙箱
通过加强多例模式下的 createElement 办法，负责创立元素并劫持 script、link、style 三个标签的创立动作
加强 appendChild、insertBefore 办法，负责增加元素，并劫持 script、link、style 三个标签的增加动作，依据是否是主利用调用决定标签是插入到主利用还是微利用，并且将 proxy 对象传递给微利用，作为其全局对象，以达到 JS 隔离的目标
初始化实现后返回一个 free 函数，会在微利用卸载时被调用，负责革除 patch、缓存动静增加的款式（因为微利用被卸载后所有的相干 DOM 元素都会被删掉）
free 函数执行实现后返回 rebuild 函数，在微利用从新挂载时会被调用，负责向微利用增加方才缓存的动静款式
其实严格来说这个款式沙箱有点徒有虚名，真正的款式隔离是 严格款式隔离模式 和 scoped css 模式 提供的，当然如果开启了 scoped css，款式沙箱中动静增加的款式也会通过 scoped css 的解决
回到正题，款式沙箱理论做的事件其实很简略，就是将动静增加的 script、link、style 这三个元素插入到对的地位，属于主利用的插入主利用，属于微利用的插入到对应的微利用中，不便微利用卸载的时候一起删除，
当然款式沙箱还额定做了两件事：
- 在卸载之前为动静增加款式做缓存，在微利用从新挂载时再插入到微利用内
- 将 proxy 对象传递给 execScripts 函数，将其设置为微利用的执行上下文
以上内容就是对运行时沙箱的一个总结，更加具体的实现过程，可持续浏览上面的源码剖析局部
源码剖析
接下来就进入令人头昏脑胀的源码剖析局部，说实话，运行时沙箱这段代码还是有一些难度的，我在浏览 qiankun 源码的时候，这部分内容反反复复浏览了好几遍，github
入口地位 – createSandbox
/**
* 生成运行时沙箱，这个沙箱其实由两局部组成 => JS 沙箱（执行上下文）、款式沙箱
*
* @param appName 微利用名称
* @param elementGetter getter 函数，通过该函数能够获取 <div id="__qiankun_microapp_wrapper_for_${appInstanceId}__" data-name="${appName}">${template}</div>
* @param singular 是否单例模式
* @param scopedCSS
* @param excludeAssetFilter 指定局部非凡的动静加载的微利用资源（css/js) 不被 qiankun 劫持解决
*/
export function createSandbox(
appName: string,
elementGetter: () => HTMLElement | ShadowRoot,
singular: boolean,
scopedCSS: boolean,
excludeAssetFilter?: (url: string) => boolean,
) {
/**
* JS 沙箱，通过 proxy 代理 window 对象，记录 window 对象上属性的增删改查，区别在于：* 单例模式间接代理了原生 window 对象，记录原生 window 对象的增删改查，当 window 对象激活时复原 window 对象到上次行将失活时的状态，* 失活时复原 window 对象到初始初始状态
* 多例模式代理了一个全新的对象，这个对象是复制的 window 对象的一部分不可配置属性，所有的更改都是基于这个 fakeWindow 对象，从而保障多个实例
* 之间属性互不影响
* 前面会将 sandbox.proxy 作为微利用的全局对象，所有的操作都在这个 proxy 对象上，这就是 JS 沙箱的原理
*/
let sandbox: SandBox;
if (window.Proxy) {sandbox = singular ? new LegacySandbox(appName) : new ProxySandbox(appName);
} else {
// 不反对 proxy 的浏览器，通过 diff 形式实现的沙箱
sandbox = new SnapshotSandbox(appName);
}
/**
* 款式沙箱
*
* 加强多例模式下的 createElement 办法，负责创立元素并劫持 script、link、style 三个标签的创立动作
* 加强 appendChild、insertBefore 办法，负责增加元素，并劫持 script、link、style 三个标签的增加动作，做一些非凡的解决 =>
* 依据是否是主利用调用决定标签是插入到主利用还是微利用，并且将 proxy 对象传递给微利用，作为其全局对象，以达到 JS 隔离的目标
* 初始化实现后返回 free 函数，会在微利用卸载时被调用，负责革除 patch、缓存动静增加的款式（因为微利用被卸载后所有的相干 DOM 元素都会被删掉）* free 函数执行实现后返回 rebuild 函数，在微利用从新挂载时会被调用，负责向微利用增加方才缓存的动静款式
*
* 其实严格来说这个款式沙箱有点徒有虚名，真正的款式隔离是之前说的 严格款式隔离模式 和 scoped css 模式 提供的，当然如果开启了 scoped css，* 款式沙箱中动静增加的款式也会通过 scoped css 的解决；回到正题，款式沙箱理论做的事件其实很简略，将动静增加的 script、link、style
* 这三个元素插入到对的地位，属于主利用的插入主利用，属于微利用的插入到对应的微利用中，不便微利用卸载的时候一起删除，* 当然款式沙箱还额定做了两件事：一、在卸载之前为动静增加款式做缓存，在微利用从新挂载时再插入到微利用内，二、将 proxy 对象传递给 execScripts
* 函数，将其设置为微利用的执行上下文
*/
const bootstrappingFreers = patchAtBootstrapping(
appName,
elementGetter,
sandbox,
singular,
scopedCSS,
excludeAssetFilter,
);
// mounting freers are one-off and should be re-init at every mounting time
// mounting freers 是一次性的，应该在每次挂载时从新初始化
let mountingFreers: Freer[] = [];
let sideEffectsRebuilders: Rebuilder[] = [];
return {
proxy: sandbox.proxy,
/**
* 沙箱被 mount
* 可能是从 bootstrap 状态进入的 mount
* 也可能是从 unmount 之后再次唤醒进入 mount
* mount 时重建副作用(rebuild 函数），即微利用在被卸载时心愿从新挂载时做的一些事件，比方重建缓存的动静款式
*/
async mount() {
/* ------------------------------------------ 因为有上下文依赖（window），以下代码执行程序不能变 ------------------------------------------ */
/* ------------------------------------------ 1. 启动 / 复原 沙箱 ------------------------------------------ */
sandbox.active();
const sideEffectsRebuildersAtBootstrapping = sideEffectsRebuilders.slice(0, bootstrappingFreers.length);
const sideEffectsRebuildersAtMounting = sideEffectsRebuilders.slice(bootstrappingFreers.length);
// must rebuild the side effects which added at bootstrapping firstly to recovery to nature state
if (sideEffectsRebuildersAtBootstrapping.length) {
// 微利用再次挂载时重建方才缓存的动静款式
sideEffectsRebuildersAtBootstrapping.forEach(rebuild => rebuild());
}
/* ------------------------------------------ 2. 开启全局变量补丁 ------------------------------------------*/
// render 沙箱启动时开始劫持各类全局监听，尽量不要在利用初始化阶段有 事件监听 / 定时器 等副作用
mountingFreers = patchAtMounting(appName, elementGetter, sandbox, singular, scopedCSS, excludeAssetFilter);
/* ------------------------------------------ 3. 重置一些初始化时的副作用 ------------------------------------------*/
// 存在 rebuilder 则表明有些副作用须要重建
// 当初只看到针对 umi 的那个 patchHistoryListener 有 rebuild 操作
if (sideEffectsRebuildersAtMounting.length) {sideEffectsRebuildersAtMounting.forEach(rebuild => rebuild());
}
// clean up rebuilders，卸载时会再填充回来
sideEffectsRebuilders = [];},
/**
* 复原 global 状态，使其能回到利用加载之前的状态
*/
// 撤销初始化和挂载阶段打的 patch；缓存微利用心愿本人再次被挂载时须要做的一些事件（rebuild），比方重建动静样式表；失活微利用
async unmount() {// record the rebuilders of window side effects (event listeners or timers)
// note that the frees of mounting phase are one-off as it will be re-init at next mounting
// 卸载时，执行 free 函数，开释初始化和挂载时打的 patch，存储所有的 rebuild 函数，在微利用再次挂载时重建通过 patch 做的事件（副作用）sideEffectsRebuilders = [...bootstrappingFreers, ...mountingFreers].map(free => free());
sandbox.inactive();},
};
}
JS 沙箱
SingularProxySandbox 单例 JS 沙箱
/**
* 基于 Proxy 实现的单例模式下的沙箱，间接操作原生 window 对象，并记录 window 对象的增删改查，在每次微利用切换时初始化 window 对象；* 激活时：将 window 对象复原到上次行将失活时的状态
* 失活时：将 window 对象复原为初始状态
*
* TODO: 为了兼容性 singular 模式下仍旧应用该沙箱，等新沙箱稳固之后再切换
*/
export default class SingularProxySandbox implements SandBox {
// 沙箱期间新增的全局变量
private addedPropsMapInSandbox = new Map<PropertyKey, any>();
// 沙箱期间更新的全局变量，key 为被更新的属性，value 为被更新的值
private modifiedPropsOriginalValueMapInSandbox = new Map<PropertyKey, any>();
// 继续记录更新的 (新增和批改的) 全局变量的 map，用于在任意时刻做 snapshot
private currentUpdatedPropsValueMap = new Map<PropertyKey, any>();
name: string;
proxy: WindowProxy;
type: SandBoxType;
sandboxRunning = true;
// 激活沙箱
active() {
// 如果沙箱由失活 -> 激活，则复原 window 对象到上次失活时的状态
if (!this.sandboxRunning) {this.currentUpdatedPropsValueMap.forEach((v, p) => setWindowProp(p, v));
}
// 切换沙箱状态为 激活
this.sandboxRunning = true;
}
// 失活沙箱
inactive() {
// 开发环境，打印被扭转的全局属性
if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') {console.info(`[qiankun:sandbox] ${this.name} modified global properties restore...`, [...this.addedPropsMapInSandbox.keys(),
...this.modifiedPropsOriginalValueMapInSandbox.keys(),]);
}
// restore global props to initial snapshot
// 将被更改的全局属性再改回去
this.modifiedPropsOriginalValueMapInSandbox.forEach((v, p) => setWindowProp(p, v));
// 新增的属性删掉
this.addedPropsMapInSandbox.forEach((_, p) => setWindowProp(p, undefined, true));
// 切换沙箱状态为 失活
this.sandboxRunning = false;
}
constructor(name: string) {
this.name = name;
this.type = SandBoxType.LegacyProxy;
const {addedPropsMapInSandbox, modifiedPropsOriginalValueMapInSandbox, currentUpdatedPropsValueMap} = this;
const self = this;
const rawWindow = window;
const fakeWindow = Object.create(null) as Window;
const proxy = new Proxy(fakeWindow, {set(_: Window, p: PropertyKey, value: any): boolean {if (self.sandboxRunning) {if (!rawWindow.hasOwnProperty(p)) {
// 属性不存在，则增加
addedPropsMapInSandbox.set(p, value);
} else if (!modifiedPropsOriginalValueMapInSandbox.has(p)) {
// 如果以后 window 对象存在该属性，且 record map 中未记录过，则记录该属性初始值，阐明是更改已存在的属性
const originalValue = (rawWindow as any)[p];
modifiedPropsOriginalValueMapInSandbox.set(p, originalValue);
}
currentUpdatedPropsValueMap.set(p, value);
// 间接设置原生 window 对象，因为是单例模式，不会有其它的影响
// eslint-disable-next-line no-param-reassign
(rawWindow as any)[p] = value;
return true;
}
if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') {console.warn(`[qiankun] Set window.${p.toString()} while sandbox destroyed or inactive in ${name}!`);
}
// 在 strict-mode 下，Proxy 的 handler.set 返回 false 会抛出 TypeError，在沙箱卸载的状况下应该疏忽谬误
return true;
},
get(_: Window, p: PropertyKey): any {
// avoid who using window.window or window.self to escape the sandbox environment to touch the really window
// or use window.top to check if an iframe context
// see https://github.com/eligrey/FileSaver.js/blob/master/src/FileSaver.js#L13
if (p === 'top' || p === 'parent' || p === 'window' || p === 'self') {return proxy;}
// 间接从原生 window 对象拿数据
const value = (rawWindow as any)[p];
return getTargetValue(rawWindow, value);
},
// trap in operator
// see https://github.com/styled-components/styled-components/blob/master/packages/styled-components/src/constants.js#L12
has(_: Window, p: string | number | symbol): boolean {return p in rawWindow;},
});
this.proxy = proxy;
}
}
/**
* 在 window 对象上设置 key value 或 删除指定属性(key)
* @param prop key
* @param value value
* @param toDelete 是否删除
*/
function setWindowProp(prop: PropertyKey, value: any, toDelete?: boolean) {if (value === undefined && toDelete) {// 删除 window[key]
delete (window as any)[prop];
} else if (isPropConfigurable(window, prop) && typeof prop !== 'symbol') {// window[key] = value
Object.defineProperty(window, prop, { writable: true, configurable: true});
(window as any)[prop] = value;
}
}
ProxySandbox 多例 JS 沙箱
// 记录被激活的沙箱的数量
let activeSandboxCount = 0;
/**
* 基于 Proxy 实现的多例模式下的沙箱
* 通过 proxy 代理 fakeWindow 对象，所有的更改都是基于 fakeWindow，这点和单例不一样（很重要），* 从而保障每个 ProxySandbox 实例之间属性互不影响
*/
export default class ProxySandbox implements SandBox {
/** window 值变更记录 */
private updatedValueSet = new Set<PropertyKey>();
name: string;
type: SandBoxType;
proxy: WindowProxy;
sandboxRunning = true;
// 激活
active() {
// 被激活的沙箱数 + 1
if (!this.sandboxRunning) activeSandboxCount++;
this.sandboxRunning = true;
}
// 失活
inactive() {if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') {console.info(`[qiankun:sandbox] ${this.name} modified global properties restore...`, [...this.updatedValueSet.keys(),
]);
}
// 被激活的沙箱数 - 1
clearSystemJsProps(this.proxy, --activeSandboxCount === 0);
this.sandboxRunning = false;
}
constructor(name: string) {
this.name = name;
this.type = SandBoxType.Proxy;
const {updatedValueSet} = this;
const self = this;
const rawWindow = window;
// 全局对象上所有不可配置属性都在 fakeWindow 中，且其中具备 getter 属性的属性还存在 propertesWithGetter map 中，value 为 true
const {fakeWindow, propertiesWithGetter} = createFakeWindow(rawWindow);
const descriptorTargetMap = new Map<PropertyKey, SymbolTarget>();
// 判断全局对象是否存在指定属性
const hasOwnProperty = (key: PropertyKey) => fakeWindow.hasOwnProperty(key) || rawWindow.hasOwnProperty(key);
const proxy = new Proxy(fakeWindow, {set(target: FakeWindow, p: PropertyKey, value: any): boolean {
// 如果沙箱在运行，则更新属性值并记录被更改的属性
if (self.sandboxRunning) {
// 设置属性值
// @ts-ignore
target[p] = value;
// 记录被更改的属性
updatedValueSet.add(p);
// 不必管，和 systemJs 无关
interceptSystemJsProps(p, value);
return true;
}
if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') {console.warn(`[qiankun] Set window.${p.toString()} while sandbox destroyed or inactive in ${name}!`);
}
// 在 strict-mode 下，Proxy 的 handler.set 返回 false 会抛出 TypeError，在沙箱卸载的状况下应该疏忽谬误
return true;
},
// 获取执行属性的值
get(target: FakeWindow, p: PropertyKey): any {if (p === Symbol.unscopables) return unscopables;
// avoid who using window.window or window.self to escape the sandbox environment to touch the really window
// see https://github.com/eligrey/FileSaver.js/blob/master/src/FileSaver.js#L13
if (p === 'window' || p === 'self') {return proxy;}
if (
p === 'top' ||
p === 'parent' ||
(process.env.NODE_ENV === 'test' && (p === 'mockTop' || p === 'mockSafariTop'))
) {
// if your master app in an iframe context, allow these props escape the sandbox
if (rawWindow === rawWindow.parent) {return proxy;}
return (rawWindow as any)[p];
}
// proxy.hasOwnProperty would invoke getter firstly, then its value represented as rawWindow.hasOwnProperty
if (p === 'hasOwnProperty') {return hasOwnProperty;}
// mark the symbol to document while accessing as document.createElement could know is invoked by which sandbox for dynamic append patcher
if (p === 'document') {document[attachDocProxySymbol] = proxy;
// remove the mark in next tick, thus we can identify whether it in micro app or not
// this approach is just a workaround, it could not cover all the complex scenarios, such as the micro app runs in the same task context with master in som case
// fixme if you have any other good ideas
nextTick(() => delete document[attachDocProxySymbol]);
return document;
}
// 以上内容都是一些非凡属性的解决
// 获取特定属性，如果属性具备 getter，阐明是原生对象的那几个属性，否则是 fakeWindow 对象上的属性（原生的或者用户设置的)
// eslint-disable-next-line no-bitwise
const value = propertiesWithGetter.has(p) ? (rawWindow as any)[p] : (target as any)[p] || (rawWindow as any)[p];
return getTargetValue(rawWindow, value);
},
// 判断是否存在指定属性
// see https://github.com/styled-components/styled-components/blob/master/packages/styled-components/src/constants.js#L12
has(target: FakeWindow, p: string | number | symbol): boolean {return p in unscopables || p in target || p in rawWindow;},
getOwnPropertyDescriptor(target: FakeWindow, p: string | number | symbol): PropertyDescriptor | undefined {
/*
as the descriptor of top/self/window/mockTop in raw window are configurable but not in proxy target, we need to get it from target to avoid TypeError
see https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Global_Objects/Proxy/handler/getOwnPropertyDescriptor
> A property cannot be reported as non-configurable, if it does not exists as an own property of the target object or if it exists as a configurable own property of the target object.
*/
if (target.hasOwnProperty(p)) {const descriptor = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(target, p);
descriptorTargetMap.set(p, 'target');
return descriptor;
}
if (rawWindow.hasOwnProperty(p)) {const descriptor = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(rawWindow, p);
descriptorTargetMap.set(p, 'rawWindow');
// A property cannot be reported as non-configurable, if it does not exists as an own property of the target object
if (descriptor && !descriptor.configurable) {descriptor.configurable = true;}
return descriptor;
}
return undefined;
},
// trap to support iterator with sandbox
ownKeys(target: FakeWindow): PropertyKey[] {return uniq(Reflect.ownKeys(rawWindow).concat(Reflect.ownKeys(target)));
},
defineProperty(target: Window, p: PropertyKey, attributes: PropertyDescriptor): boolean {const from = descriptorTargetMap.get(p);
/*
Descriptor must be defined to native window while it comes from native window via Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(window, p),
otherwise it would cause a TypeError with illegal invocation.
*/
switch (from) {
case 'rawWindow':
return Reflect.defineProperty(rawWindow, p, attributes);
default:
return Reflect.defineProperty(target, p, attributes);
}
},
deleteProperty(target: FakeWindow, p: string | number | symbol): boolean {if (target.hasOwnProperty(p)) {
// @ts-ignore
delete target[p];
updatedValueSet.delete(p);
return true;
}
return true;
},
});
this.proxy = proxy;
}
}
createFakeWindow
/**
* 拷贝全局对象上所有不可配置属性到 fakeWindow 对象，并将这些属性的属性描述符改为可配置的而后解冻
* 将启动具备 getter 属性的属性再存入 propertiesWithGetter map 中
* @param global 全局对象 => window
*/
function createFakeWindow(global: Window) {// 记录 window 对象上的 getter 属性，原生的有：window、document、location、top，比方：Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(window, 'window') => {set: undefined, enumerable: true, configurable: false, get: ƒ}
// propertiesWithGetter = {"window" => true, "document" => true, "location" => true, "top" => true, "__VUE_DEVTOOLS_GLOBAL_HOOK__" => true}
const propertiesWithGetter = new Map<PropertyKey, boolean>();
// 存储 window 对象中所有不可配置的属性和值
const fakeWindow = {} as FakeWindow;
/*
copy the non-configurable property of global to fakeWindow
see https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Global_Objects/Proxy/handler/getOwnPropertyDescriptor
> A property cannot be reported as non-configurable, if it does not exists as an own property of the target object or if it exists as a configurable own property of the target object.
*/
Object.getOwnPropertyNames(global)
// 遍历出 window 对象所有不可配置属性
.filter(p => {const descriptor = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(global, p);
return !descriptor?.configurable;
})
.forEach(p => {
// 失去属性描述符
const descriptor = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(global, p);
if (descriptor) {
// 获取其 get 属性
const hasGetter = Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(descriptor, 'get');
/*
make top/self/window property configurable and writable, otherwise it will cause TypeError while get trap return.
see https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Reference/Global_Objects/Proxy/handler/get
> The value reported for a property must be the same as the value of the corresponding target object property if the target object property is a non-writable, non-configurable data property.
*/
if (
p === 'top' ||
p === 'parent' ||
p === 'self' ||
p === 'window' ||
(process.env.NODE_ENV === 'test' && (p === 'mockTop' || p === 'mockSafariTop'))
) {
// 将 top、parent、self、window 这几个属性由不可配置改为可配置
descriptor.configurable = true;
/*
The descriptor of window.window/window.top/window.self in Safari/FF are accessor descriptors, we need to avoid adding a data descriptor while it was
Example:
Safari/FF: Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(window, 'top') -> {get: function, set: undefined, enumerable: true, configurable: false}
Chrome: Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(window, 'top') -> {value: Window, writable: false, enumerable: true, configurable: false}
*/
if (!hasGetter) {
// 如果这几个属性没有 getter，则阐明由 writeable 属性，将其设置为可写
descriptor.writable = true;
}
}
// 如果存在 getter，则以该属性为 key，true 为 value 存入 propertiesWithGetter map
if (hasGetter) propertiesWithGetter.set(p, true);
// 将属性和形容设置到 fakeWindow 对象，并且解冻属性描述符，不然有可能会被更改，比方 zone.js
// freeze the descriptor to avoid being modified by zone.js
// see https://github.com/angular/zone.js/blob/a5fe09b0fac27ac5df1fa746042f96f05ccb6a00/lib/browser/define-property.ts#L71
rawObjectDefineProperty(fakeWindow, p, Object.freeze(descriptor));
}
});
return {
fakeWindow,
propertiesWithGetter,
};
}
SnapshotSandbox
function iter(obj: object, callbackFn: (prop: any) => void) {
// eslint-disable-next-line guard-for-in, no-restricted-syntax
for (const prop in obj) {if (obj.hasOwnProperty(prop)) {callbackFn(prop);
}
}
}
/**
* 基于 diff 形式实现的沙箱，用于不反对 Proxy 的低版本浏览器
*/
export default class SnapshotSandbox implements SandBox {
proxy: WindowProxy;
name: string;
type: SandBoxType;
sandboxRunning = true;
private windowSnapshot!: Window;
private modifyPropsMap: Record<any, any> = {};
constructor(name: string) {
this.name = name;
this.proxy = window;
this.type = SandBoxType.Snapshot;
}
active() {
// 记录以后快照
this.windowSnapshot = {} as Window;
iter(window, prop => {this.windowSnapshot[prop] = window[prop];
});
// 复原之前的变更
Object.keys(this.modifyPropsMap).forEach((p: any) => {window[p] = this.modifyPropsMap[p];
});
this.sandboxRunning = true;
}
inactive() {this.modifyPropsMap = {};
iter(window, prop => {if (window[prop] !== this.windowSnapshot[prop]) {
// 记录变更，复原环境
this.modifyPropsMap[prop] = window[prop];
window[prop] = this.windowSnapshot[prop];
}
});
if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') {console.info(`[qiankun:sandbox] ${this.name} origin window restore...`, Object.keys(this.modifyPropsMap));
}
this.sandboxRunning = false;
}
}
款式沙箱
patchAtBootstrapping
/**
* 初始化阶段给 createElement、appendChild、insertBefore 三个办法打一个 patch
* @param appName
* @param elementGetter
* @param sandbox
* @param singular
* @param scopedCSS
* @param excludeAssetFilter
*/
export function patchAtBootstrapping(
appName: string,
elementGetter: () => HTMLElement | ShadowRoot,
sandbox: SandBox,
singular: boolean,
scopedCSS: boolean,
excludeAssetFilter?: Function,
): Freer[] {
// 根底 patch，加强 createElement、appendChild、insertBefore 三个办法
const basePatchers = [() => patchDynamicAppend(appName, elementGetter, sandbox.proxy, false, singular, scopedCSS, excludeAssetFilter),
];
// 每一种沙箱都须要打基础 patch
const patchersInSandbox = {[SandBoxType.LegacyProxy]: basePatchers,
[SandBoxType.Proxy]: basePatchers,
[SandBoxType.Snapshot]: basePatchers,
};
// 返回一个数组，数组元素是 patch 的执行后果 => free 函数
return patchersInSandbox[sandbox.type]?.map(patch => patch());
}
patch
/**
* 加强多例模式下的 createElement 办法，负责创立元素并劫持 script、link、style 三个标签的创立动作
* 加强 appendChild、insertBefore 办法，负责增加元素，并劫持 script、link、style 三个标签的增加动作，做一些非凡的解决 =>
* 依据是否是主利用调用决定标签是插入到主利用还是微利用，并且将 proxy 对象传递给微利用，作为其全局对象，以打包 JS 隔离的目标
* 初始化实现后返回 free 函数，负责革除 patch、缓存动静增加的款式（因为微利用被卸载后所有的相干 DOM 元素都会被删掉）* free 函数执行实现后返回 rebuild 函数，rebuild 函数在微利用从新挂载时向微利用增加方才缓存的动静款式
*
* Just hijack dynamic head append, that could avoid accidentally hijacking the insertion of elements except in head.
* Such a case: ReactDOM.createPortal(<style>.test{color:blue}</style>, container),
* this could made we append the style element into app wrapper but it will cause an error while the react portal unmounting, as ReactDOM could not find the style in body children list.
* @param appName 微利用名称
* @param appWrapperGetter getter 函数，通过该函数能够获取 <div id="__qiankun_microapp_wrapper_for_${appInstanceId}__" data-name="${appName}">${template}</div>
* @param proxy window 代理
* @param mounting 是否为 mounting 阶段
* @param singular 是否为单例
* @param scopedCSS 是否弃用 scoped css
* @param excludeAssetFilter 指定局部非凡的动静加载的微利用资源（css/js) 不被 qiankun 劫持解决
*/
export default function patch(
appName: string,
appWrapperGetter: () => HTMLElement | ShadowRoot,
proxy: Window,
mounting = true,
singular = true,
scopedCSS = false,
excludeAssetFilter?: CallableFunction,
): Freer {
// 动静样式表，存储所有动静增加的款式
let dynamicStyleSheetElements: Array<HTMLLinkElement | HTMLStyleElement> = [];
// 在多例模式下加强 createElement 办法，让其除了能够创立元素，还能够了劫持创立 script、link、style 元素的状况
const unpatchDocumentCreate = patchDocumentCreateElement(
appName,
appWrapperGetter,
singular,
proxy,
dynamicStyleSheetElements,
);
// 加强 appendChild、insertBefore、removeChild 三个元素；除了本职工作之外，appendChild 和 insertBefore 还能够额定解决 script、style、link
// 三个标签的插入，能够依据状况决定元素被插入到微利用模版空间中还是主利用模版空间，removeChild 也是能够依据状况移除主利用的元素还是移除微利用中这三个元素
const unpatchDynamicAppendPrototypeFunctions = patchHTMLDynamicAppendPrototypeFunctions(
appName,
appWrapperGetter,
proxy,
singular,
scopedCSS,
dynamicStyleSheetElements,
excludeAssetFilter,
);
// 记录初始化的次数
if (!mounting) bootstrappingPatchCount++;
// 记录挂载的次数
if (mounting) mountingPatchCount++;
// 初始化实现后返回 free 函数，负责革除 patch、缓存动静增加的款式、返回 rebuild 函数，rebuild 函数在微利用从新挂载时向微利用增加方才缓存的动静款式
return function free() {
// bootstrap patch just called once but its freer will be called multiple times
if (!mounting && bootstrappingPatchCount !== 0) bootstrappingPatchCount--;
if (mounting) mountingPatchCount--;
// 判断所有微利用是否都被卸载了
const allMicroAppUnmounted = mountingPatchCount === 0 && bootstrappingPatchCount === 0;
// 微利用都卸载当前移除 patch, release the overwrite prototype after all the micro apps unmounted
unpatchDynamicAppendPrototypeFunctions(allMicroAppUnmounted);
unpatchDocumentCreate(allMicroAppUnmounted);
// 因为微利用被卸载的时候会删除掉方才动静增加的款式，这里缓存了动静增加的款式内容，在微利用卸载后从新挂载时就能够用了
dynamicStyleSheetElements.forEach(stylesheetElement => {if (stylesheetElement instanceof HTMLStyleElement && isStyledComponentsLike(stylesheetElement)) {if (stylesheetElement.sheet) {
// record the original css rules of the style element for restore
setCachedRules(stylesheetElement, (stylesheetElement.sheet as CSSStyleSheet).cssRules);
}
}
});
// 返回一个 rebuild 函数，微利用从新挂载时调用
return function rebuild() {
// 遍历动静样式表
dynamicStyleSheetElements.forEach(stylesheetElement => {
// 像微利用容器中增加款式节点
document.head.appendChild.call(appWrapperGetter(), stylesheetElement);
// 增加款式内容到款式节点，这个款式内容从方才的缓存中找
if (stylesheetElement instanceof HTMLStyleElement && isStyledComponentsLike(stylesheetElement)) {const cssRules = getCachedRules(stylesheetElement);
if (cssRules) {
// eslint-disable-next-line no-plusplus
for (let i = 0; i < cssRules.length; i++) {const cssRule = cssRules[i];
(stylesheetElement.sheet as CSSStyleSheet).insertRule(cssRule.cssText);
}
}
}
});
// As the hijacker will be invoked every mounting phase, we could release the cache for gc after rebuilding
if (mounting) {dynamicStyleSheetElements = [];
}
};
};
}
patchDocumentCreateElement
/**
* 多例模式下加强 createElement 办法，让其除了具备创立元素性能之外，还能够劫持创立 script、link、style 这三个元素的状况
* @param appName 微利用名称
* @param appWrapperGetter
* @param singular
* @param proxy
* @param dynamicStyleSheetElements
*/
function patchDocumentCreateElement(
appName: string,
appWrapperGetter: () => HTMLElement | ShadowRoot,
singular: boolean,
proxy: Window,
dynamicStyleSheetElements: HTMLStyleElement[],) {
// 如果是单例模式间接 return
if (singular) {return noop;}
// 以微利用运行时的 proxy 为 key，存储该微利用的一些信息，比方 名称、proxy、微利用模版、自定义样式表等
proxyContainerInfoMapper.set(proxy, { appName, proxy, appWrapperGetter, dynamicStyleSheetElements, singular});
// 第一个微利用初始化时会执行这段，加强 createElement 办法，让其除了能够创立元素之外，还能够劫持 script、link、style 三个标签的创立动作
if (Document.prototype.createElement === rawDocumentCreateElement) {
Document.prototype.createElement = function createElement<K extends keyof HTMLElementTagNameMap>(
this: Document,
tagName: K,
options?: ElementCreationOptions,
): HTMLElement {
// 创立元素
const element = rawDocumentCreateElement.call(this, tagName, options);
// 劫持 script、link、style 三种标签
if (isHijackingTag(tagName)) {// 上面这段仿佛没啥用，因为没发现有哪个中央执行设置，proxyContainerInfoMapper.set(this[attachDocProxySysbol])
// 获取这个货色的值，而后将该值增加到 element 对象上，以 attachElementContainerSymbol 为 key
const proxyContainerInfo = proxyContainerInfoMapper.get(this[attachDocProxySymbol]);
if (proxyContainerInfo) {
Object.defineProperty(element, attachElementContainerSymbol, {
value: proxyContainerInfo,
enumerable: false,
});
}
}
// 返回创立的元素
return element;
};
}
// 后续的微利用初始化时间接返回该函数，负责还原 createElement 办法
return function unpatch(recoverPrototype: boolean) {proxyContainerInfoMapper.delete(proxy);
if (recoverPrototype) {Document.prototype.createElement = rawDocumentCreateElement;}
};
}
patchTHMLDynamicAppendPrototypeFunctions
// 加强 appendChild、insertBefore、removeChild 办法，返回 unpatch 办法，解除加强
function patchHTMLDynamicAppendPrototypeFunctions(
appName: string,
appWrapperGetter: () => HTMLElement | ShadowRoot,
proxy: Window,
singular = true,
scopedCSS = false,
dynamicStyleSheetElements: HTMLStyleElement[],
excludeAssetFilter?: CallableFunction,
) {
// Just overwrite it while it have not been overwrite
if (
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.appendChild === rawHeadAppendChild &&
HTMLBodyElement.prototype.appendChild === rawBodyAppendChild &&
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.insertBefore === rawHeadInsertBefore
) {
// 加强 appendChild 办法
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.appendChild = getOverwrittenAppendChildOrInsertBefore({
rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore: rawHeadAppendChild,
appName,
appWrapperGetter,
proxy,
singular,
dynamicStyleSheetElements,
scopedCSS,
excludeAssetFilter,
}) as typeof rawHeadAppendChild;
HTMLBodyElement.prototype.appendChild = getOverwrittenAppendChildOrInsertBefore({
rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore: rawBodyAppendChild,
appName,
appWrapperGetter,
proxy,
singular,
dynamicStyleSheetElements,
scopedCSS,
excludeAssetFilter,
}) as typeof rawBodyAppendChild;
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.insertBefore = getOverwrittenAppendChildOrInsertBefore({
rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore: rawHeadInsertBefore as any,
appName,
appWrapperGetter,
proxy,
singular,
dynamicStyleSheetElements,
scopedCSS,
excludeAssetFilter,
}) as typeof rawHeadInsertBefore;
}
// Just overwrite it while it have not been overwrite
if (
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.removeChild === rawHeadRemoveChild &&
HTMLBodyElement.prototype.removeChild === rawBodyRemoveChild
) {
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.removeChild = getNewRemoveChild({
appWrapperGetter,
headOrBodyRemoveChild: rawHeadRemoveChild,
});
HTMLBodyElement.prototype.removeChild = getNewRemoveChild({
appWrapperGetter,
headOrBodyRemoveChild: rawBodyRemoveChild,
});
}
return function unpatch(recoverPrototype: boolean) {if (recoverPrototype) {
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.appendChild = rawHeadAppendChild;
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.removeChild = rawHeadRemoveChild;
HTMLBodyElement.prototype.appendChild = rawBodyAppendChild;
HTMLBodyElement.prototype.removeChild = rawBodyRemoveChild;
HTMLHeadElement.prototype.insertBefore = rawHeadInsertBefore;
}
};
}
getOverwrittenAppendChildOrInsertBefore
/**
* 加强 appendChild 和 insertBefore 办法，让其除了具备增加元素的性能之外，还具备一些其它的逻辑，比方：* 依据是否是微利用或者非凡元素决定 link、style、script 元素的插入地位是在主利用还是微利用
* 劫持 script 标签的增加，反对近程加载脚本和设置脚本的执行上下文（proxy）* @param opts
*/
function getOverwrittenAppendChildOrInsertBefore(opts: {
appName: string;
proxy: WindowProxy;
singular: boolean;
dynamicStyleSheetElements: HTMLStyleElement[];
appWrapperGetter: CallableFunction;
rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore: <T extends Node>(newChild: T, refChild?: Node | null) => T;
scopedCSS: boolean;
excludeAssetFilter?: CallableFunction;
}) {
return function appendChildOrInsertBefore<T extends Node>(
this: HTMLHeadElement | HTMLBodyElement,
newChild: T,
refChild?: Node | null,
) {
// 要插入的元素
let element = newChild as any;
// 原始办法
const {rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore} = opts;
if (element.tagName) {
// 解析参数
// eslint-disable-next-line prefer-const
let {appName, appWrapperGetter, proxy, singular, dynamicStyleSheetElements} = opts;
const {scopedCSS, excludeAssetFilter} = opts;
// 多例模式会走的一段逻辑
const storedContainerInfo = element[attachElementContainerSymbol];
if (storedContainerInfo) {
// eslint-disable-next-line prefer-destructuring
appName = storedContainerInfo.appName;
// eslint-disable-next-line prefer-destructuring
singular = storedContainerInfo.singular;
// eslint-disable-next-line prefer-destructuring
appWrapperGetter = storedContainerInfo.appWrapperGetter;
// eslint-disable-next-line prefer-destructuring
dynamicStyleSheetElements = storedContainerInfo.dynamicStyleSheetElements;
// eslint-disable-next-line prefer-destructuring
proxy = storedContainerInfo.proxy;
}
const invokedByMicroApp = singular
? // check if the currently specified application is active
// While we switch page from qiankun app to a normal react routing page, the normal one may load stylesheet dynamically while page rendering,
// but the url change listener must to wait until the current call stack is flushed.
// This scenario may cause we record the stylesheet from react routing page dynamic injection,
// and remove them after the url change triggered and qiankun app is unmouting
// see https://github.com/ReactTraining/history/blob/master/modules/createHashHistory.js#L222-L230
checkActivityFunctions(window.location).some(name => name === appName)
: // have storedContainerInfo means it invoked by a micro app in multiply mode
!!storedContainerInfo;
switch (element.tagName) {
// link 和 style
case LINK_TAG_NAME:
case STYLE_TAG_NAME: {
// 断言，newChild 为 style 或者 link 标签
const stylesheetElement: HTMLLinkElement | HTMLStyleElement = newChild as any;
// href 属性
const {href} = stylesheetElement as HTMLLinkElement;
if (!invokedByMicroApp || (excludeAssetFilter && href && excludeAssetFilter(href))) {
// 进来则阐明，这个创立元素的动作不是微利用调用的，或者是一个非凡指定不心愿被 qiankun 劫持的 link 标签
// 将其创立到主利用的下
return rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore.call(this, element, refChild) as T;
}
// 微利用容器 DOM
const mountDOM = appWrapperGetter();
// scoped css
if (scopedCSS) {css.process(mountDOM, stylesheetElement, appName);
}
// 将该元素存到样式表中
// eslint-disable-next-line no-shadow
dynamicStyleSheetElements.push(stylesheetElement);
// 参考元素
const referenceNode = mountDOM.contains(refChild) ? refChild : null;
// 将该元素在微利用的空间中创立，这样卸载微利用的时候就能够间接一起删除了
return rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore.call(mountDOM, stylesheetElement, referenceNode);
}
// script 标签
case SCRIPT_TAG_NAME: {
// 链接和文本
const {src, text} = element as HTMLScriptElement;
// some script like jsonp maybe not support cors which should't use execScripts
if (!invokedByMicroApp || (excludeAssetFilter && src && excludeAssetFilter(src))) {
// 同理，将该标签创立到主利用下
return rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore.call(this, element, refChild) as T;
}
// 微利用容器 DOM
const mountDOM = appWrapperGetter();
// 用户提供的 fetch 办法
const {fetch} = frameworkConfiguration;
// 参考节点
const referenceNode = mountDOM.contains(refChild) ? refChild : null;
// 如果 src 存在，则阐明是一个外联脚本
if (src) {
// 执行近程加载，将 proxy 设置为脚本的全局对象，来达到 JS 隔离的目标
execScripts(null, [src], proxy, {
fetch,
strictGlobal: !singular,
beforeExec: () => {
Object.defineProperty(document, 'currentScript', {get(): any {return element;},
configurable: true,
});
},
success: () => {
// we need to invoke the onload event manually to notify the event listener that the script was completed
// here are the two typical ways of dynamic script loading
// 1. element.onload callback way, which webpack and loadjs used, see https://github.com/muicss/loadjs/blob/master/src/loadjs.js#L138
// 2. addEventListener way, which toast-loader used, see https://github.com/pyrsmk/toast/blob/master/src/Toast.ts#L64
const loadEvent = new CustomEvent('load');
if (isFunction(element.onload)) {element.onload(patchCustomEvent(loadEvent, () => element));
} else {element.dispatchEvent(loadEvent);
}
element = null;
},
error: () => {const errorEvent = new CustomEvent('error');
if (isFunction(element.onerror)) {element.onerror(patchCustomEvent(errorEvent, () => element));
} else {element.dispatchEvent(errorEvent);
}
element = null;
},
});
// 创立一个正文元素，示意该 script 标签被 qiankun 劫持解决了
const dynamicScriptCommentElement = document.createComment(`dynamic script ${src} replaced by qiankun`);
return rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore.call(mountDOM, dynamicScriptCommentElement, referenceNode);
}
// 阐明该 script 是一个内联脚本
execScripts(null, [`<script>${text}</script>`], proxy, {
strictGlobal: !singular,
success: element.onload,
error: element.onerror,
});
// 创立一个正文元素，示意该 script 标签被 qiankun 劫持解决了
const dynamicInlineScriptCommentElement = document.createComment('dynamic inline script replaced by qiankun');
return rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore.call(mountDOM, dynamicInlineScriptCommentElement, referenceNode);
}
default:
break;
}
}
// 调用原始办法，插入元素
return rawDOMAppendOrInsertBefore.call(this, element, refChild);
};
}
getNewRemoveChild
/**
* 加强 removeChild，让其能够依据状况决定是从主利用中移除指定元素，还是从微利用中移除 script、style、link 元素
* 如果是被劫持元素，则从微利用中移除，否则从主利用中移除
* @param opts
*/
function getNewRemoveChild(opts: {
appWrapperGetter: CallableFunction;
headOrBodyRemoveChild: typeof HTMLElement.prototype.removeChild;
}) {return function removeChild<T extends Node>(this: HTMLHeadElement | HTMLBodyElement, child: T) {
// 原始的 removeChild
const {headOrBodyRemoveChild} = opts;
try {const { tagName} = child as any;
// 当移除的元素是 script、link、style 之一时非凡解决
if (isHijackingTag(tagName)) {
// 微利用容器空间
let {appWrapperGetter} = opts;
// 新建时设置的，storedContainerInfo 蕴含了微利用的一些信息，不过 storedContainerInfo 应该是始终为 undefeind，因为设置地位的代码仿佛永远不会被执行
const storedContainerInfo = (child as any)[attachElementContainerSymbol];
if (storedContainerInfo) {
// eslint-disable-next-line prefer-destructuring
// 微利用的包裹元素，也能够说微利用模版
appWrapperGetter = storedContainerInfo.appWrapperGetter;
}
// 从微利用容器空间中移除该元素
// container may had been removed while app unmounting if the removeChild action was async
const container = appWrapperGetter();
if (container.contains(child)) {return rawRemoveChild.call(container, child) as T;
}
}
} catch (e) {console.warn(e);
}
// 从主利用中移除元素
return headOrBodyRemoveChild.call(this, child) as T;
};
}
patchAtMounting
在微利用的挂载阶段会被调用，次要负责给各个全局变量（办法）打 patch
export function patchAtMounting(
appName: string,
elementGetter: () => HTMLElement | ShadowRoot,
sandbox: SandBox,
singular: boolean,
scopedCSS: boolean,
excludeAssetFilter?: Function,
): Freer[] {
const basePatchers = [
// 定时器 patch
() => patchInterval(sandbox.proxy),
// 事件监听 patch
() => patchWindowListener(sandbox.proxy),
// fix umi bug
() => patchHistoryListener(),
// 初始化阶段时的那个 patch
() => patchDynamicAppend(appName, elementGetter, sandbox.proxy, true, singular, scopedCSS, excludeAssetFilter),
];
const patchersInSandbox = {[SandBoxType.LegacyProxy]: [...basePatchers],
[SandBoxType.Proxy]: [...basePatchers],
[SandBoxType.Snapshot]: basePatchers,
};
return patchersInSandbox[sandbox.type]?.map(patch => patch());
}
patch => patchInterval
/**
* 定时器 patch，设置定时器时自动记录定时器 id，革除定时器时主动删除已革除的定时器 id，开释 patch 时主动革除所有未被革除的定时器，并复原定时器办法
* @param global = windowProxy
*/
export default function patch(global: Window) {let intervals: number[] = [];
// 革除定时器，并从 intervals 中革除曾经革除的 定时器 id
global.clearInterval = (intervalId: number) => {intervals = intervals.filter(id => id !== intervalId);
return rawWindowClearInterval(intervalId);
};
// 设置定时器，并记录定时器的 id
global.setInterval = (handler: Function, timeout?: number, ...args: any[]) => {const intervalId = rawWindowInterval(handler, timeout, ...args);
intervals = [...intervals, intervalId];
return intervalId;
};
// 革除所有的定时器，并复原定时器办法
return function free() {intervals.forEach(id => global.clearInterval(id));
global.setInterval = rawWindowInterval;
global.clearInterval = rawWindowClearInterval;
return noop;
};
}
patch => patchWindowListener
/**
* 监听器 patch，增加事件监听时自动记录事件的回调函数，移除时主动删除事件的回调函数，开释 patch 时主动删除所有的事件监听，并复原监听函数
* @param global windowProxy
*/
export default function patch(global: WindowProxy) {
// 记录各个事件的回调函数
const listenerMap = new Map<string, EventListenerOrEventListenerObject[]>();
// 设置监听器
global.addEventListener = (
type: string,
listener: EventListenerOrEventListenerObject,
options?: boolean | AddEventListenerOptions,
) => {
// 从 listenerMap 中获取曾经存在的该事件的回调函数
const listeners = listenerMap.get(type) || [];
// 保留该事件的所有回调函数
listenerMap.set(type, [...listeners, listener]);
// 设置监听
return rawAddEventListener.call(window, type, listener, options);
};
// 移除监听器
global.removeEventListener = (
type: string,
listener: EventListenerOrEventListenerObject,
options?: boolean | AddEventListenerOptions,
) => {
// 从 listenerMap 中移除该事件的指定回调函数
const storedTypeListeners = listenerMap.get(type);
if (storedTypeListeners && storedTypeListeners.length && storedTypeListeners.indexOf(listener) !== -1) {storedTypeListeners.splice(storedTypeListeners.indexOf(listener), 1);
}
// 移除事件监听
return rawRemoveEventListener.call(window, type, listener, options);
};
// 开释 patch，移除所有的事件监听
return function free() {
// 移除所有的事件监听
listenerMap.forEach((listeners, type) =>
[...listeners].forEach(listener => global.removeEventListener(type, listener)),
);
// 复原监听函数
global.addEventListener = rawAddEventListener;
global.removeEventListener = rawRemoveEventListener;
return noop;
};
}
链接
-
微前端专栏
- 微前端框架 之 qiankun 从入门到源码剖析
- HTML Entry 源码剖析
- 微前端框架 之 single-spa 从入门到精通
- github
感激各位的：点赞 、 珍藏 和评论，咱们下期见。
当学习成为了习惯，常识也就变成了常识，扫码关注微信公众号，独特学习、提高。文章已收录到 github，欢送 Watch 和 Star。
正文完